Welcome to Dapogo Official Website!
Penghantaran Seluruh Malaysia
Masakan kampung premium sedia untuk anda di mana sahaja dan bila-bila masa.
Welcome to Dapogo Official Website!
What Is Asam Pedas? Johor vs Melaka, and How It Differs From Tom Yum

Dish Guides

What Is Asam Pedas? Johor vs Melaka, and How It Differs From Tom Yum

Our own plantMelaka Halal Hub, Serkam
54 products7 categories
24 months, ambientour published specification
Updated 20 November 202620 Nov 2026•31 min readminBahasa Melayu
DapoGo Asam Pedas Daging Tetel 300g retort pouch

DapoGo Asam Pedas Daging Tetel, 300g retort pouch

Asam pedas is a Malay stew that is sour and hot at the same time, from tamarind and dried chillies, usually cooked with fish and sometimes with chicken or beef. Johor and Melaka are most often told apart by their leaves and spices: the Johor style usually uses daun kesum (Vietnamese coriander), ginger and lemongrass, while the Melaka style uses kaffir lime leaves, fenugreek and belacan. The line is not fixed. Some Melaka versions also use daun kesum and torch ginger flower, and sources disagree on which gravy is thicker.

What asam pedas actually is, which ingredients set the Johor and Melaka styles apart, a recipe for a kilo of fish, which fish suit it and what they cost in Malaysian markets in November 2026, what a serving costs whether you use a ready-to-eat pouch, a paste or cook from scratch, and how it differs from tom yum.

Published 18 September 2026 · Written by the DapoGo team; we make a Johor-style asam pedas in pouches at our factory in Melaka Halal Hub, Serkam · Part of our DapoGo dish guide

Jump to: asam pedas recipe for a kilo of fish · cost-per-serving table · fish prices, November 2026

The short version

  • According to chef Mohd Faizal Abd Wahid in Kuali (September 2025), Johor asam pedas leans on ginger, lemongrass, dried shrimp and daun kesum, while Melaka asam pedas leans on fenugreek, belacan and kaffir lime leaves.
  • No official source settles which gravy is thicker: Kuali (2025) says Johor’s is thicker, but Rasa.my (May 2026) says the Melaka version is usually the thicker one.
  • The Johor asam pedas recipe Rasa.my published for 1kg of ikan mayong uses 20 dried chillies, 5 shallots, 10 sprigs of daun kesum and a cup of tamarind water.
  • The median price of Indian mackerel (ikan kembung) in Melaka on 1–19 November 2026 was RM18.90 a kilo, and sliced Spanish mackerel (tenggiri) RM42.39 a kilo, according to the Ministry of Domestic Trade’s PriceCatcher data (our calculation).
  • A pot made with DapoGo’s Pes Asam Pedas Johor (RM17), a kilo of kembung and some okra costs about RM37.90 for 4–5 people. From scratch with the same fish it is about RM24.66, before counting belacan, lemongrass and the leaves.
On this page17 sections

What is asam pedas, and where does it come from?

Asam pedas is a stew that combines sourness, usually from tamarind, with the heat of dried chillies, cooked with fish, chicken or beef. Its exact origin is uncertain. It is shared heritage of the Malay and Minangkabau peoples, and in Malaysia it is most often linked with Melaka and Johor, two states that have argued over who owns it.

The Wikipedia encyclopedia describes asam pedas as part of the shared culinary heritage of both Malay and Minangkabau traditions, and says that is why its exact origin is unclear. One theory it mentions places its birth in the port of Melaka, where sea trade brought local people into contact with Chinese and Portuguese communities. The sourness most often comes from tamarind pulp soaked in water and strained, though some places use asam keping (dried garcinia slices) or lime juice.

Ownership has been a political question. In June 2013, The Star reported Melaka’s plan to patent its asam pedas, and Johor’s then executive councillor for youth, sports, culture and heritage, Datuk Zulkurnain Kamisan, replied that the dish was not exclusive to Melaka but common across the country. In September 2016, he announced that the Johor government had agreed to gazette asam pedas and laksa Johor as heritage dishes. Whatever the style, one rule holds for every cook:

“Jika masakan dihasilkan hanya masam atau pedas saja, maka ia bukan masakan asam pedas.” (If a dish is only sour or only spicy, it is not asam pedas.)
— Chef Mohd Faizal Abd Wahid, hotel chef with more than 18 years’ experience, in Kuali (2025)

What is the difference between Johor and Melaka asam pedas?

The differences people mention most are in the leaves, spices and vegetables. Johor asam pedas uses daun kesum, ginger, lemongrass and dried shrimp, sometimes torch ginger flower (bunga kantan), with pickled mustard greens (sawi jeruk). Melaka asam pedas uses kaffir lime leaves, fenugreek and belacan, with okra or aubergine. The main ingredient differs too: Melaka usually uses stingray or Indian mackerel, while Johor happily uses fish, chicken or beef.

The most quoted list comes from chef Mohd Faizal Abd Wahid, who set out the differences in a Kuali article on 9 September 2025. An almost identical list, including daun kesum against kaffir lime leaves and pickled mustard greens against okra, appeared on the Raja Lepak site in March 2020, so this is the picture that circulates among asam pedas fans, not an official rule.

Melaka asam pedas Johor asam pedas
Base ingredients Shallots, garlic, fresh turmeric, turmeric powder, belacan, fenugreek, ground dried chilli, tamarind water Ginger, bruised lemongrass and dried shrimp, besides shallots and turmeric
Leaves Kaffir lime leaves Daun kesum
Vegetables Usually none, or okra and aubergine Pickled mustard greens
Gravy Thinner Fairly thick
Colour of the gravy Brownish Bright red
Taste Stronger and more concentrated Lighter
Main ingredient Usually stingray or Indian mackerel Fish, chicken or beef, to taste

Source of the table: chef Mohd Faizal Abd Wahid, Kuali, 9 September 2025.

Other sources add detail, and not all of them agree. Wikipedia describes the Melaka version as more soupy and typically made with fenugreek seeds, cumin, candlenuts and galangal, with kaffir lime leaves often used in place of daun kesum. For Johor, Sr. Ts. Dr. Mohammad Ashraf Abdul Rahman, head of UTHM’s Centre for Heritage Conservation, Archaeology, Survey and Procedure (Kasturi), who cooked a Johor recipe at the 2022 Melaka Heritage Cooking Festival, explained that Johor’s recipe uses daun kesum and bunga kantan to lift the aroma. Rasa.my, in a May 2026 article, writes that the Melaka version sometimes uses daun kesum and bunga kantan to add aroma too. So those leaves do not belong to one state alone.

Rosmarlinda Kamarudin, editor of SAJI, summed up the debate on UtusanTV in October 2025: “Apa pun pandangan dan pendapat, itu subjektif” (whatever the views and opinions, it is subjective). That is why we read “Johor style” or “Melaka style” on a label as a guide to flavour, not a fixed recipe.

Which asam pedas gravy is thicker: Johor or Melaka?

There is no agreed answer. Kuali and Raja Lepak say Johor’s gravy is thicker and Melaka’s thinner, a UTHM heritage specialist cooked his Johor recipe “dengan tekstur kuah yang lebih pekat” (with a thicker gravy), and the Johor asam pedas recipe on Rasa.my (2024) says “jangan cair” (don’t make it thin). Rasa.my itself, in a May 2026 article, says the opposite. A 2016 study by Ahmad Sahir Jais, as summarised in the last row of the table below, shows Johor is not one style either: southern Johor cooks a thick gravy, while Tangkak, Muar, Batu Pahat and Kluang in the north prefer it thinner.

We set out what each source says in one table so the disagreement is plain. It matters because many buyers choose “Johor style” or “Melaka style” assuming the texture is fixed, when the most quoted sources do not agree.

Source Year Johor gravy Melaka gravy
Raja Lepak 2020 Thicker Thinner, brownish
Dr. Mohammad Ashraf Abdul Rahman, UTHM (UTHM news) 2022 “tekstur kuah yang lebih pekat” (his Johor recipe) Not compared
Rasa.my, ikan mayong asam pedas recipe 2024 “jangan cair, biar pekat tapi jangan pekat sangat” (not thin, thick but not too thick) Not compared
Chef Mohd Faizal Abd Wahid, Kuali 2025 Fairly thick Thinner
Rasa.my, Johor vs Melaka article 2026 Tends to be thinner, with sharper sourness Usually thicker and more spiced
Wikipedia, citing Ahmad Sahir Jais (2016) – South: thick, often with black pepper. North (Tangkak, Muar, Batu Pahat, Kluang): thinner, usually without black pepper More soupy

Southern Johor sometimes adds salted mustard greens (sawi masin) for extra sourness, according to the same reference. The two Johor recipes we drew on, on Rasa.my (2024) and theAsianparent (2023), both use black pepper, the trait linked with the south. So when someone says “Johor asam pedas is definitely thick”, they most likely grew up with the southern version. Someone from Muar or Batu Pahat may have grown up with a thinner gravy.

DapoGo’s Johor-style asam pedas sits at the thick end. Our Asam Pedas Daging Tetel product page describes the gravy as “pekat, likat, melekat” (thick, rich and clinging) and calls it “asam pedas oldschool Johor, resepi keluarga tukang masak turun-temurun. Bukan versi cair, bukan versi shortcut”: a family recipe handed down through generations of cooks, not a thin version and not a shortcut. The beef trimmings are “dimasak lama sampai rempah meresap habis” (slow-cooked until the spices soak right in). Our Pes Asam Pedas Johor is described as “Bukan style cair, bukan manis”: not thin, not sweet.

Asam pedas, asam padeh and gerang asam: the same dish or different?

All three are one family of dishes with different names by place: asam padeh is the Minangkabau name, asam keueung the Acehnese, and gerang asam the Baba Nyonya name. The base is always a gravy soured with asam and made hot with chillies, but the souring agent, the spices and the main ingredient change from one community to the next.

The list of names comes from Wikipedia, which also records several versions. The Minangkabau cook asam padeh daging, a beef version usually soured with asam kandis rather than tamarind. The Peranakan version, gerang asam ikan, uses more root spices than the Malay versions, and Melaka has a Peranakan beef asam pedas eaten with pulut tetal (glutinous rice). Among Johor’s Bugis-Malay community, asam pedas is also called nasu metti and is served with burasak and lepat lui rice cakes, especially at Hari Raya.

For a buyer, the names matter when reading a recipe or a label. An asam padeh recipe from Sumatra may use asam kandis and spices that Johor or Melaka asam pedas does not, and the Johor-against-Melaka table above does not describe these versions. DapoGo’s asam pedas is Johor style: both its product pages list tamarind (asam jawa), not asam kandis.

What goes into asam pedas, and what is in DapoGo’s?

The recipes we compare in this article, from Rasa.my and theAsianparent, share the same core: chilli (usually dried chillies), tamarind water, onions or shallots, garlic and belacan, with ginger in almost all of them and fresh turmeric in more than half. What changes the style is the “marker” ingredients: daun kesum, lemongrass and bunga kantan for Johor, or fenugreek, kaffir lime leaves and seed spices such as cumin for Melaka. Vegetables such as aubergine, okra and tomatoes are often added.

Wikipedia lists the key ingredients of asam pedas as onion, ginger, chilli paste, turmeric, fermented shrimp paste, salt, daun kesum and water. Family recipes vary. A young participant from Masjid Tanah, Melaka, at the 2022 Melaka Heritage Cooking Festival cooked his mother’s recipe with dried chillies, shallots, belacan, lime leaves and tamarind as the main ingredients, and his mother told him every family has its own way of cooking it and its own recipe.

The table below compares each style’s marker ingredients with the ingredient lists on the product pages of DapoGo’s two asam pedas products. It shows something rarely mentioned: belacan, which Kuali lists for Melaka, is also in both of our Johor-style recipes.

Marker ingredient Linked with Asam Pedas Daging Tetel pouch Pes Asam Pedas Johor
Daun kesum Johor (Kuali, UTHM) Yes Yes
Ginger Johor (Kuali) Yes Yes
Lemongrass Johor (Kuali) Yes Not listed
Bunga kantan (torch ginger flower) Johor (UTHM) Yes Not listed
Dried shrimp Johor (Kuali) Not listed Not listed
Belacan Melaka (Kuali) Yes Yes
Fenugreek Melaka (Kuali) Not listed Not listed
Kaffir lime leaves Melaka (Kuali) Not listed Not listed

The “Linked with” column shows a tendency, not a rule: Rasa.my (May 2026) writes that the Melaka version sometimes uses daun kesum and bunga kantan too.

The Asam Pedas Daging Tetel product page lists beef trimmings (daging tetel, which the page describes as “lembut, berlemak”, soft and fatty), dried chilli, belacan, tamarind, daun kesum, bunga kantan, shallots, garlic, ginger, lemongrass, sugar, salt and permitted flavouring, with no preservatives. The Pes Asam Pedas Johor page lists dried chilli, shallots, garlic, ginger, belacan, tamarind, daun kesum, salt, sugar and permitted flavouring.

How is asam pedas cooked: a recipe for a kilo of fish, or with a paste?

From scratch, asam pedas is cooked in three stages: fry the ground spice paste and dried chillies until the oil separates, add the tamarind water and the leaves, then add the fish and cook it only just enough so it stays whole. For a kilo of fish, the Johor recipe Rasa.my published uses 20 dried chillies and a cup of tamarind water. With DapoGo’s Pes Asam Pedas Johor, there is no frying stage: add 200–300ml of water and a kilo of protein, and boil until cooked.

The recipe below is not DapoGo’s. The Johor column is the ikan mayong asam pedas recipe Rasa.my published on 14 August 2024, and the Melaka column is the Melaka asam pedas recipe theAsianparent Malaysia published on 14 November 2023. Both are for about a kilo of fish, and we give the amounts as they were published.

Asam pedas recipe for a kilo of fish: Johor and Melaka

Ingredient Johor style (Rasa.my, 2024) Melaka style (theAsianparent, 2023)
Fish 1kg ikan mayong with its roe 1 red snapper (ikan merah), 900g
Dried chillies 20, boiled and ground 30, boiled, deseeded and ground
Shallots 5 10–15
Large onion 1 1, sliced for frying
Garlic 3 cloves 6 cloves (1 sliced, 5 ground)
Fresh turmeric 2 inches 3 knobs
Ginger 2 inches 1 inch
Belacan A little 1 inch (½ tablespoon), toasted
Seed spices 1 spoon black pepper, crushed 1 tablespoon coriander seeds, ½ tablespoon fennel (jintan manis), ½ tablespoon cumin (jintan putih), ½ tablespoon black pepper, ½ tablespoon fenugreek
Leaves and flower 10 sprigs daun kesum, 1 torch ginger flower halved 5–6 kaffir lime leaves
Sour 1 cup tamarind water 1 cup tamarind juice
Water As needed 2–3 cups
Oil Plenty for frying, the excess ladled off after cooking ¾ cup
Vegetables Okra, to taste Okra and 1 tomato
Seasoning Salt, sugar, a little seasoning Salt, seasoning powder (optional)

Sources: Johor column, “Resipi Asam Pedas Ikan Mayung Dengan Telur Mayung”, Rasa.my, 14 August 2024; Melaka column, “Perbezaan Asam Pedas Johor Dan Asam Pedas Melaka”, theAsianparent Malaysia, 14 November 2023 (both in Malay). Neither source states how many it serves. For comparison, DapoGo’s Pes Asam Pedas Johor sets 1kg of protein for about 4–5 people.

Step by step, with the sign that each stage is done

  1. Make the spice paste. Both recipes boil the dried chillies first, then grind them with shallots, garlic, ginger, fresh turmeric and belacan. The Melaka recipe also grinds coriander seeds, fennel, cumin and black pepper, and deseeds the chillies.
  2. Fry. The Melaka style fries the fenugreek first until fragrant, then the sliced onion and garlic until soft. Add the ground paste and fry over medium heat. Sign it is done: the paste separates from the oil (pecah minyak) and smells fragrant.
  3. Add the sour, the leaves and the fish. The Johor style adds the tamarind water with the daun kesum and torch ginger flower, then the fish and enough water. The Melaka style adds the kaffir lime leaves, water and salt, fries again until dry, then the tamarind water, water and fish, and cooks it until it boils.
  4. Simmer. Lower the heat and simmer until the fish is cooked. No longer: Rasa.my warns that overcooked fish falls apart.
  5. Season and finish. Season with salt and sugar. Add the okra (and the tomato for the Melaka style) at the end, and turn off the heat once the okra is tender.

Both recipes give a sign for each stage, not minutes, and we have not added times the sources do not give. What tells you a stage is done is what you see in the pot: oil separating on top of the paste, fish that is cooked but still whole, and okra that is tender before the heat goes off.

The method with DapoGo’s Pes Asam Pedas Johor

  1. Pour one packet of paste (400g) into a pot. The product page says: no frying and no extra spices needed.
  2. Add 200–300ml of water.
  3. Add a kilo of fish, chicken, beef or beef trimmings, to taste.
  4. Boil until cooked. “10 minit siap” (ready in 10 minutes) is the product page’s estimate. Beef or beef trimmings are simmered until tender.
  5. Add okra or aubergine if you like. One pot serves about 4–5 people.

Control over the heat differs between these methods. The Johor and Melaka recipes above use 20 and 30 dried chillies, and a young participant at the 2022 Melaka Heritage Cooking Festival admitted the hardest part was getting the amounts right: “kalau terlebih cili kering pedas pula” (too much dried chilli and it gets too hot). Cooking from scratch, the amount of chilli is in your hands. With a paste or a ready-to-eat pouch, the heat is set by the recipe. Other village-cooking pastes are in our cooking paste range.

Asam pedas with stingray, kembung, mayong or jenahak: how does the cooking change?

The basic steps are the same for every fish. What changes is how the fish is cut, when the extras go in and what sours the gravy. In the recipes Rasa.my published, stingray (ikan pari) is cut into pieces and goes in with the daun kesum, kembung is halved, mayong roe is half-boiled first, and jenahak (mangrove red snapper) is cooked with candlenuts in the spice paste so the gravy is richer.

Fish In the recipe Cooking notes Source
Stingray (pari) 6–7 pieces; another recipe uses 1kg Goes in with the daun kesum once the gravy boils, then tomato and okra. Choose fresh stingray because “isinya lebih manis dan tidak hanyir” (the flesh is sweeter and not fishy). Rasa.my (July 2024; May 2026)
Indian mackerel (kembung) 6 fish, halved Goes in with the okra after the gravy boils. The tomato goes in only after the fish is cooked, and then the heat goes off. Rasa.my (May 2019)
Mayong 1kg with its roe The roe is half-boiled first and added with the okra at the end: “Tak perlu masak lama kerana telur akan jadi keras” (no need to cook it long or the roe turns hard). Rasa.my (August 2024)
Jenahak 1 fish 5 candlenuts (buah keras) in the spice paste “supaya ada rasa lemak” (for richness); tamarind plus a handful of asam gelugor; kaffir lime leaves. Rasa.my (December 2024)
Red snapper (ikan merah) 1 fish, 900g Melaka style: fenugreek, seed spices and kaffir lime leaves, as in the recipe above. theAsianparent (November 2023)

The fish can also be cooked whole or with only the head, according to Wikipedia, and Rasa.my (May 2026) lists fish head, beef trimmings and chicken as variations. The jenahak recipe shows one more thing: candlenuts, linked with the Melaka version, turn up in a home recipe that names no state. The other difference is the souring: the jenahak recipe adds asam gelugor to the tamarind, and its tip is blunt: “Jangan takut-takut untuk letak asam jawa atau asam gelugor banyak” (don’t be afraid to use plenty of tamarind or asam gelugor).

Which fish suits asam pedas best, and what does it cost now?

There is no official list. Chef Mohd Faizal (Kuali) names stingray or kembung for the Melaka style, SAJI editor Rosmarlinda Kamarudin (UtusanTV) says people in Johor like ikan mayong and wolf herring (ikan parang), and Rasa.my (May 2026) names stingray, tenggiri, kembung and red snapper among the most popular. On 1–19 November 2026, the median price a kilo in Melaka was RM12.99 for yellowstripe scad, RM18.90 for kembung and RM42.39 for sliced tenggiri, according to PriceCatcher data.

Participants at the 2022 Melaka Heritage Cooking Festival cooked 250 dishes of kembung asam pedas at the same time, a Malaysia Book of Records entry. Wikipedia’s list is wider, including mackerel tuna (tongkol), tuna, red snapper, pangasius (patin) and cuttlefish. The price table below also covers yellowstripe scad (selar kuning) and jenahak, plus beef and chicken for those who do not use fish.

The prices below are medians we calculated from PriceCatcher’s daily price records, open data from the Ministry of Domestic Trade on data.gov.my, for 1 to 19 November 2026. A median means half the records were cheaper and half dearer.

Fish prices for asam pedas, November 2026

Item (per kilo) Melaka Johor All Malaysia
Yellowstripe scad (selar kuning) RM12.99 RM12.00 RM12.00
Indian mackerel (kembung, 8–12 fish a kilo) RM18.90 RM18.00 RM16.00
Spanish mackerel (tenggiri batang, sliced) RM42.39 RM48.99 RM45.00
Mangrove red snapper (jenahak, sliced) RM42.99 RM47.99 RM45.99
Local beef (lean) RM36.00 RM39.00 RM36.00
Whole cleaned chicken (standard) RM7.89 RM7.70 RM8.19
Okra (kacang bendi) RM8.00 RM8.99 RM8.99

Source: PriceCatcher, Ministry of Domestic Trade (data.gov.my), file pricecatcher_2026-11.parquet, records for 1–19 November 2026, medians calculated by us. PriceCatcher item codes: kembung 1476, selar kuning 69, tenggiri 1438, jenahak 1915, beef 1432, chicken 1, okra 96. The Melaka figures for tenggiri (12 premises) and beef (5 premises) come from few premises, so treat them as a rough guide. PriceCatcher recorded no stingray or wolf herring prices in this period.

Kembung in Melaka and Johor cost more than the national median in November 2026: RM18.90 and RM18.00 a kilo against RM16.00. Data.gov.my itself notes that PriceCatcher complements, rather than replaces, Consumer Price Index data, so prices at your shop may differ.

What does a serving of asam pedas cost: pouch, paste or from scratch?

The Asam Pedas Daging Tetel pouch is the smallest spend for one meal: RM13 for 2–3 people, or RM4.33–RM6.50 a person, but that is 300g of finished dish shared between 2–3 people. A pot made with the RM17 asam pedas paste and a kilo of kembung costs about RM37.90 for 4–5 people (RM7.58–RM9.48 a person), and each person gets 200–250g of raw fish. Counted per 100g, the paste pot is cheaper: about RM2.30 per 100g of ingredients, against RM4.33 per 100g of finished dish in the pouch.

Cooking from scratch with the same fish is the cheapest in our example, at about RM24.66 a pot, because its main paste ingredients cost only about RM3.76 in Melaka’s markets.

The example uses dapogo.com prices on 20 November 2026 and PriceCatcher median prices for Melaka on 1–19 November 2026. The 250g of okra and the paste amounts for option F are our own assumptions, and for F we assume a kilo of fish also serves 4–5, the same ratio as the paste. “Per 100g” is worked out on the total weight of what you buy (fish weighed with the bone), not the cooked weight. Rice is not included.

Option What you buy Total Serves Per person Per 100g
A. Ready-to-eat pouch 1 Asam Pedas Daging Tetel pouch, 300gm (RM13.00) RM13.00 2–3 RM4.33–RM6.50 RM4.33 (finished dish)
B. Paste + kembung Paste RM17.00 + 1kg kembung RM18.90 + 250g okra RM2.00 RM37.90 4–5 RM7.58–RM9.48 RM2.30
C. Paste + chicken Paste RM17.00 + 1kg cleaned chicken RM7.89 RM24.89 4–5 RM4.98–RM6.22 RM1.78
D. Paste + beef Paste RM17.00 + 1kg local beef RM36.00 RM53.00 4–5 RM10.60–RM13.25 RM3.79
E. Paste + sliced tenggiri Paste RM17.00 + 1kg sliced tenggiri RM42.39 + 250g okra RM2.00 RM61.39 4–5 RM12.28–RM15.35 RM3.72
F. From scratch + kembung Paste ingredients RM3.76 + 1kg kembung RM18.90 + 250g okra RM2.00 RM24.66 4–5 (assumed) RM4.93–RM6.17 RM1.34

How to read this: options A and B are not the same portion, which is why the “per 100g” column sits next to “per person”. Options B and E differ only in the fish, yet the gap is RM23.49 a pot, more than the price of a packet of paste (RM17). Option C gives a per-person cost close to the pouch (RM4.98–RM6.22 against RM4.33–RM6.50), but with 200–250g of raw chicken each. For option D, “10 minit siap” is the paste page’s figure; beef is simmered until tender.

Option F: what is in the RM3.76 of paste ingredients?

Ingredient Our assumption Melaka median Cost
Curly dried chillies 50g RM20.99 a kilo RM1.05
Shallots (Indian import) 100g RM4.50 a kilo RM0.45
Large onion (Holland) 150g RM3.99 a kilo RM0.60
Garlic (Chinese import) 30g RM10.00 a kilo RM0.30
Mature ginger 30g RM8.49 a kilo RM0.25
Fresh turmeric 30g RM8.50 a kilo RM0.26
Tamarind with seeds 100g (half a 200g pack) RM1.20 a pack RM0.60
Packet cooking oil 100g RM2.50 a kilo RM0.25
Total RM3.76

Price source: PriceCatcher Melaka, 1–19 November 2026 (item codes 1899, 1442, 129, 1564, 95, 108, 1489, 918). The amounts are our assumptions for a kilo of fish, because the recipes above count chillies, cloves and inches, not grams. Not counted: belacan, lemongrass, daun kesum, torch ginger flower, black pepper and fenugreek (no PriceCatcher records for them in November 2026), nor salt, sugar and gas.

So the paste costs RM17 against about RM3.76 of market ingredients, before the belacan, lemongrass and leaves. What it replaces is the work and the shopping: the product page says the paste needs “tak perlu tumis, tak perlu tambah rempah” (no frying, no extra spices), one packet does 1kg of protein, and it keeps 2 years at room temperature until opened. Cooking from scratch gives you full control over the chilli, the sourness and how thick the gravy is.

What mistakes do people make cooking and storing asam pedas?

The mistakes cooks warn about most are a lopsided taste, paste that has not separated from the oil, dried chillies added by guesswork, and so much water that the sourness disappears. After cooking, the usual mistakes are putting a hot pot straight into the fridge, and leaving an opened paste at room temperature.

  1. A lopsided taste. Rasa.my (May 2026) advises: “Jangan terlalu masam atau terlalu pedas biar seimbang supaya setiap sudu kuah terasa ‘padu'” (not too sour or too hot, balanced so every spoonful of gravy tastes full). Taste the gravy before adding more tamarind or chilli.
  2. Tamarind and fish in before the paste separates from the oil. Rasa.my writes that the chilli paste must be fried until it truly separates from the oil “supaya kuah tidak berbau mentah” (so the gravy does not smell raw), and calls this the key to a gravy that is not fishy and keeps better. Wait until the oil sits on top of the paste before any liquid or fish goes in.
  3. Dried chillies by guesswork. The recipes for about a kilo of fish in this article use 20 to 30 dried chillies, and Rasa.my’s stingray recipe (2024) uses 25 for 6–7 pieces of fish. If you are not sure how much heat your family likes, start at the low end and taste before adding more.
  4. Too much water. Water adds gravy but dilutes the sourness. The kembung recipe on Rasa.my (2019) lets you add as much water as the gravy you want, but warns “paling penting jangan sampai hilang rasa masam” (most important, do not lose the sourness).
  5. A hot pot straight into the fridge. Malaysia’s National Security Council (MKN) advises letting food cool completely first so the temperature inside the fridge does not rise. The UK Food Standards Agency (FSA) asks for cooked food to go into the fridge within one to two hours, so do not leave the pot on the stove overnight.
  6. An opened paste left in the cupboard. The 2-year room-temperature shelf life on DapoGo’s Pes Asam Pedas Johor page is for an unopened packet. Once opened, the page asks for the paste to be kept in the chiller.

Asam pedas if you are allergic to shrimp or do not eat fish: what are the options?

People who must avoid shrimp should be careful with asam pedas, because every recipe in this article, and both DapoGo asam pedas products, use belacan, which is made from shrimp. People who do not eat fish can cook a chicken or beef asam pedas, which the Johor style readily accepts.

Avoiding shrimp or seafood. Malaysia’s Food Regulations 1985 define belacan as a fish product in the form of a paste obtained by salt fermentation of fresh shrimp or prawn, and “fish and fish product” is among the ingredients known to cause hypersensitivity that must be declared on the label. Both DapoGo asam pedas products list belacan, and the Pes Asam Pedas Johor page states “Allergen: Mengandungi belacan” (contains belacan). If you must avoid shrimp, neither is for you.

Not eating fish. Wikipedia records chicken asam pedas (asam pedas ayam) as a common adaptation, and Kuali says the Johor style takes chicken and beef. Our ready-to-eat pouch uses beef trimmings. Our paste can be cooked with chicken, and in the cost example above, a paste pot with a kilo of chicken costs RM24.89 for 4–5 people.

How long does asam pedas keep, in a pouch and homemade?

An unopened retort pouch of asam pedas keeps at room temperature; DapoGo states its pouches keep for 2 years at room temperature with no fridge. Homemade asam pedas is ordinary leftovers: MKN advises a fridge at 1–4°C and no more than 3 days. The UK’s FSA is stricter, at 48 hours or freeze it.

Why does a pouch last so long? According to the Faculty of Food Science and Technology at Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM), retort food is heated in an airtight pack at temperatures usually above 121°C, so that harmful micro-organisms including Clostridium botulinum are inactivated, and retort food usually keeps safely for one to two years. In its briefing for factory visitors, DapoGo sums the process up in four words, “Cook – Seal – Sterilize – Shelf Stable”, and likens a retort to a “Giant Scientific Pressure Cooker”. The full explanation is in how long retort food really lasts and our retort glossary.

Type Store it How long According to
DapoGo retort pouch, unopened Room temperature 2 years DapoGo product page
Pes Asam Pedas Johor, unopened Room temperature 2 years DapoGo product page
Pes Asam Pedas Johor, opened Chiller Not stated DapoGo product page
Homemade asam pedas Fridge at 1–4°C No more than 3 days MKN

Before eating leftovers, MKN advises heating stored food through thoroughly, and looking, smelling and tasting first. Label containers with the name of the food and the date it was stored, another MKN tip, so you know when day three arrives. An unopened pouch needs no fridge at all, which is why it can go where there is none; see our guide to camping food without a fridge.

How do you heat asam pedas from a pouch?

DapoGo’s product page keeps it simple: heat the unopened pouch in boiling water for about 2 minutes, open it, and serve with hot rice. The asam pedas in the pouch is cooked before the pouch is sealed and sterilised, so 2 minutes in boiling water only warms the dish; it does not cook it. UPM explains that retort food needs only brief heating with hot water or a chemical heater, and can even be eaten without heating.

  1. Bring a pot of water to the boil.
  2. Put in the unopened pouch and leave it for about 2 minutes until hot.
  3. Lift it out carefully, cut it open and pour it into a bowl.
  4. Serve with hot rice. One pouch serves 2–3 people.

No stove? DapoGo also sells a Heat Pad (RM3), a heater activated with water only; its product page says to wait about 10–15 minutes. Other methods are in our heating guide. Like other village dishes? Read our rendang guide and gulai, curry and masak lemak compared.

How is asam pedas different from tom yum?

Both are sour and hot, but they are built differently. Asam pedas is a Malay stew whose sourness comes from tamarind cooked into the gravy. Tom yum is a family of hot and sour Thai soups, and its lime juice and fish sauce go in at the end because heat destroys their taste.

According to Wikipedia, the name tom yum comes from two Thai words: tom refers to the boiling process and yam means “mixed”. Its aroma comes from lemongrass, kaffir lime leaves, galangal and chillies. Thailand also has tom khlong, a hot and sour soup which, like asam pedas, gets its sourness from tamarind rather than lime juice.

Asam pedas Tom yum
What it is A Malay stew, sour and hot A family of hot and sour Thai soups
Where the sourness comes from Tamarind, sometimes asam keping or lime, cooked into the gravy Lime juice, added at the end
Aromatics Daun kesum, bunga kantan or kaffir lime leaves, by style Lemongrass, kaffir lime leaves, galangal, chillies
Usual main ingredient Fish, chicken or beef Fish, prawns, mixed seafood, chicken

Common questions about asam pedas

Where does asam pedas come from?

Its exact origin is uncertain. Wikipedia calls asam pedas shared heritage of Malay and Minangkabau traditions, with one theory placing its birth in the port of Melaka. The Star reported that Melaka planned to patent its asam pedas in 2013, and Johor objected that the dish is common across the country. In 2016, Johor agreed to gazette asam pedas as a state heritage dish.

Why does asam pedas use daun kesum and torch ginger flower?

For aroma. UTHM heritage specialist Dr. Mohammad Ashraf Abdul Rahman explained that Johor’s recipe uses daun kesum and bunga kantan to lift the aroma, and Rasa.my writes that torch ginger flower, daun kesum and tamarind water together make the gravy more fragrant. The Melaka style usually uses kaffir lime leaves instead, according to Kuali.

Does Johor asam pedas use black pepper?

Some of it does. Wikipedia, citing a 2016 study by Ahmad Sahir Jais, says southern Johor asam pedas often uses black pepper, while northern Johor towns such as Muar and Batu Pahat usually leave it out. The Johor asam pedas recipe on Rasa.my (2024) uses a spoon of crushed black pepper, and theAsianparent (2023) says the Johor style needs only daun kesum and black pepper.

Which fish is cheapest for asam pedas right now?

Of the fish in our price table, yellowstripe scad (selar kuning) was the cheapest in PriceCatcher data for 1–19 November 2026: a median of RM12.00 a kilo across Malaysia and RM12.99 in Melaka. Kembung was at a median of RM16.00 a kilo nationally, while sliced tenggiri was around RM45.00 a kilo. We calculated these medians from the Ministry of Domestic Trade’s open data.

Where should an opened asam pedas paste be kept?

In the chiller. DapoGo’s Pes Asam Pedas Johor product page gives a shelf life of 2 years at room temperature for an unopened packet, and says the paste must be kept in the chiller once opened. One packet is for 1kg of protein, enough for about 4–5 people, so most families use it in one go.

DapoGo asam pedas pouch or paste: which one suits you, and where can you get it?

Choose the Asam Pedas Daging Tetel pouch (RM13, for 2–3 people) if you want a finished dish in 2 minutes with no cooking, and the Pes Asam Pedas Johor (RM17, one packet for 1kg of protein, 4–5 people) if you want to cook your own fish, chicken or beef without frying a spice paste. Both are Johor style with daun kesum and belacan, and both keep 2 years at room temperature until opened.

The paste’s product page lists its uses as a home kitchen staple, for working mothers and busy families, for travel and emergency food, and for small kenduri or feeding a crowd. The pouch’s page suggests it as a home stock of dishes, for eating at the office, as food for travel or abroad, and as emergency food. To plan a week of meals with pouches, see our week of ready-to-eat meals on a budget.

Try the Johor-style beef asam pedas pouch with your own rice, or the 400g Johor asam pedas paste if you want to cook your own fish. Other dishes are in our ready-to-eat dishes, and questions about halal status and delivery are answered in our FAQ. DapoGo sells through dapogo.com, Shopee, TikTok Shop, Lazada, its WhatsApp catalogue and Halal Street UK. Which products each channel lists can change, so before you order, message us on WhatsApp and ask which asam pedas you can get where you live.

Want to try DapoGo asam pedas? WhatsApp us on 011-5501 3391 or browse all products.

Sources

  1. Kuali, Fatin Shahar, “Nampak macam sama, banyak beza asam pedas Melaka dan Johor… Mana satu pilihan hati?”, 9 September 2025 (in Malay): kuali.com
  2. Raja Lepak, “Apa beza Asam Pedas Johor dan Asam Pedas Melaka?”, 12 March 2020 (in Malay): rajalepak.com
  3. Rasa.my, Firdaus Izzuddin, “Asam Pedas Melaka Johor”, 3 May 2026 (in Malay): rasa.my
  4. Rasa.my, “Resipi Asam Pedas Ikan Mayung Dengan Telur Mayung. Kuah Buat Pekat, Baru Sedap”, 14 August 2024 (in Malay): rasa.my
  5. Rasa.my, “Bau Daun Kesum Je Dah Buat Lapar! Ni Resipi Asam Pedas Ikan Pari…”, 18 May 2026 (in Malay): rasa.my
  6. Rasa.my, “Resipi Asam Pedas Ikan Pari Paling Basic & Mudah Tapi Rasa Sedap” (Mariana Zainal’s recipe), 9 July 2024 (in Malay): rasa.my
  7. Rasa.my, “Resipi Lauk Kampung: Asam Pedas Ikan Kembung Paling Mudah, Sedap & Tak Hanyir” (Akma Abdullah’s recipe), 21 May 2019 (in Malay): rasa.my
  8. Rasa.my, “Petua Asam Pedas Ikan Jenahak Makin Sedap, Letak Buah Keras” (Nurhayati Maleq’s tip), 18 December 2024 (in Malay): rasa.my
  9. theAsianparent Malaysia, Nursyamimi, “Perbezaan Asam Pedas Johor Dan Asam Pedas Melaka, Yang Mana Satu Pilihan Anda?”, 14 November 2023 (in Malay): my.theasianparent.com
  10. UtusanTV, “Asam Pedas Melaka atau Asam Pedas Johor, mana satu yang sedap?”, 22 October 2025 (in Malay): utusantv.com
  11. UTHM News, “Masak 250 hidangan asam pedas variasi resipi”, 8 September 2022 (in Malay): news.uthm.edu.my
  12. Wikipedia, “Asam pedas” (read 20 November 2026; its Johor section cites Ahmad Sahir Jais, “Deconstructing Malay Delicacies ‘Asam Pedas’: Critical Ingredients and Flavor Profile”, 2016): en.wikipedia.org
  13. Wikipedia, “Tom yum” (read 20 November 2026): en.wikipedia.org
  14. The Star, “Malacca’s asam pedas patent plan in bad taste, says Johor”, 30 June 2013: thestar.com.my
  15. The Star, “Johor to gazette ‘laksa’ and ‘asam pedas’ as heritage dishes”, 30 September 2016: thestar.com.my
  16. Ministry of Domestic Trade, PriceCatcher (data.gov.my), file pricecatcher_2026-11.parquet, records for 1–19 November 2026, medians calculated by us: data.gov.my
  17. National Security Council (MKN), “Tip Keselamatan Makanan Di Rumah Pada Bulan Ramadan”, 11 March 2026 (in Malay): mkn.gov.my
  18. National Security Council (MKN), “Tips Menyimpan Makanan Di Dalam Peti Sejuk”, 4 September 2024 (in Malay): mkn.gov.my
  19. Food Standards Agency (UK), “How to chill, freeze and defrost food safely”: gov.uk
  20. Dr. Ezzat Mohamad Azman, Faculty of Food Science and Technology, UPM, “Makanan Retort Untuk Mangsa Banjir” (in Malay): food.upm.edu.my
  21. Ministry of Health Malaysia, Food Regulations 1985 (updated to August 2026), regulations 11(5) and 163: hq.moh.gov.my

Shopping cart

0
image/svg+xml

No products in the cart.

Continue Shopping